The crossing of space may do much to turn men's minds outwards and away from their present tribal squabbles.

Arthur C Clarke

 

 

Latest FeedBack

British Genius Has St...
British Genius Has St...
British Genius Has St...
British Genius Has St...

Last Hour Online

26 guests and 3 members

Bookmark and Share

Hover Mouse to Share Item

Support the Initiative

  Catalyze The Species
   
 

Geo Status

 Solar X-rays:
Status
Geomagnetic Field:
Status
Which Reality Do You Prefer? Uk Skeptics Interview PDF Print E-mail
Written by davID   
Tuesday, 01 December 2009
exopoliticsuk, exopolitics
 
Bad Psychics and their associated popular R.I. Podcasting arm got in touch and asked for an introduction to what the exopolitics community is all about. So in episode 22, one I'm pleased to say adjacent to British biologist Rupert Sheldrake, David Griffin obliged and took the usual questions from skeptical enquirers. 
 
!-New-! Responses and video evidence added to issues raised in interview.
 
:: Read More or scroll down for the full part one audio stream ::

As skeptics go -  this lot are friendly enough and in fact there's a good chance that behind the facade of many contemporary skeptics is someone pretty interested in the wider scheme of reality... they just take a different route to the rest of us.

One point needs making when you look at their chosen use language: exopolitics is neither based in the 'esoteric' nor is it linked to the supernatural. These are real issues with a full data-set.

Ultimately we could suggest that it's all about choice - reality is to an extent plastic and self-generated: what do you want to be your dominant reality?? A dull, Newtonian universe where everything can be explained by pseudo logical steps or one that involves embracing mystery? As we discussed - the UFO issue is not something final or 'out-there' -  it's central to us as human beings and is a developing part of the core evolutionary story.

Interview October 2009 -  UK Skeptics and Exopolitics 

  

Interview October 2009 -  UK Skeptics and Exopolitics Update - Also with Nick Pope's extra interview


Download a copy of the main discussion RIPodcast-Exouk

Skip to 30 mins or so in for the actual interview and to avoid Skeptic banter.   

 


Response to points raised... see comments.

- Point of contention #1: Lazar was employed [contrary to the RI Podcast presenters' views] on Edward Teller 's say so at S4 or Area51.

Bob Lazar Story #1

   

Bob Lazar Story #2

   

Bob Lazar Story #3

 

- Point of contention #2:  Trystan from the RI podcast claimed in the Exopolitics interview that Jim came up with the symbols *after* hypnosis... this is false as you will see:

 

Sgt Jim Penniston discusses his military notebook and symbols made at the time whilst observing the craft on the ground which was within touching distance.
 
Note the phrase from Jim's own mouth saying "I was walking around the craft taking these notes...". I think that's enough proof.
 
You should also ask yourself that if skeptics can be *so* sure of points of evidence that turn out to be wholly wrong -  what does this say about their wider methodology??!
 

The interview has received the expected, usual comments on their feedback section under the interview itself. I've responsed to some points elsewhere - http://parafort.com/ri/?p=375

For example :

"David Griffin is obvi­ously pretty intel­li­gent, but he needs a hefty dose of incredulity. I enjoyed the moment he man­aged to ref­er­ence Gödel’s incom­plete­ness the­o­rem, an orig­i­nal angle I’ve never heard a UFOlogist use before. It is how­ever com­pletely irrel­e­vant as it only per­tains to math­e­mat­i­cal proofs, not sci­en­tific evidence."


- He's never heard a UFOlogist use Godel's theorem before in this context??! Well this was EXACTLY the area that Godel would have been proud to see his idea at work I reckon.

Godel said that was within a certain framework of exploration or experiment - "truth" can never be located as a static 'result'. It's relevant to the observer of the phenomena. Instead truth is just "true within it's own terms" or as Terence McKenna said so well - something can be "true ENOUGH".

The Skeptics  want a truth they will never find - the UFO is part of the mystery of what is means to be human. You will never have the kitchen sink from a saucer placed in front of you :)

 


» 11 Comments
11"webadmin"
at Wednesday, 30 December 2009 22:43by webadmin
Update added.
10"F"
at Wednesday, 30 December 2009 20:03by Trystan
Far from being desperate, I was simply referring to the consensus of scientific opinion. Hypnotic regression has been largely discredited by the American Psychological Association. The Australian Psychological Society have said 'The available scientific and clinical evidence does not allow accurate, inaccurate, and fabricated memories to be distinguished in the absence of independent corroboration.' The unreliability of hypnotic regression to uncover memories has been shown in the most damaging fashion at sites such as http://www.bfms.org.uk 
 
Bryan - how do you KNOW Penniston wrote his notes at the time beyond faith? They clash with his original statement. And what about the inconsistency with the location of the landing site? Why did it take so long to surface? I trust you see why I have doubts? 
 
Anyhow, this is my last posting on the subject. Second part of David's interview is now up as part of Unlucky Dip #3 at www.ripodcast.co.uk (as well as some stuff from Nick Pope).
9"Jim P"
at Friday, 18 December 2009 21:53by Brian Applyard
You were right about Jim Penniston - I did not have to go and see the videos you added as it's always been known that he wrote those down At THE TIME.  
 
Skeptics ALWAYS use the hypnosis is unreliable pitch then they're getting desperate :))))
8"media proof"
at Wednesday, 02 December 2009 15:02by webadmin
OK - I've added videos that deal with just two of the points we did not agree on during the discussion.
7"Bob Lazar and Teller"
at Tuesday, 01 December 2009 21:41by webadmin
One of the disputes in the interview is that I claimed both Col Phil Corso and Bob Lazar's stories were true and had been validated over the years... 
 
At the start of this clip father of the H-Bomb Ed Teller refuses to deny knowing Lazar - I call that a nod to authenticity... 
 
Here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5G0aTO4gl Fc
6"webadmin #2"
at Tuesday, 01 December 2009 19:37by webadmin
...cont: supernatural or esoteric. In the skeptics reality testimony counts for little, neither does adopting new ways of processing and filtering data. I say futile as your [the wider 'you'!] approach seems to always want to get issue X into a lab and test it until you're happy there is a solid 3D object there for you to touch. This approach no longer works in isolation. High strangeness demands novel approaches in evaluation, not junior school rulers and compasses. 
 
The fact the UFO issue is the most freq. searched topic online after pr0n tells us there is something going on. I like the role you and yours perform but I fear with this issue esp you are carving out your own extinction by remaining as rigid as you do on the basics. This inability to shift or adapt *is* futile.  
 
However, as I said on f/book - you were a far more tolerant and humorous Skeptical crew than most and I enjoyed the time we spent. On the Jim Penniston issue - I'll prove it :) - Watch this space...
5"webadmin"
at Tuesday, 01 December 2009 19:25by webadmin
Trystan - glad you popped by to take a peek at things. I've listened to your Sheldrake interview a few times now and it was good to hear him in that context. 
 
Re comments: Really you should see my facebook comments after I posted it there also.as that was up sooner than the one here and had a fuller, balanced review to the whole interview and skepticism as a reality. I mentioned there how 'good' skeptics can contribute to evolving a debate instead of holding it back as many ppl tend to see you doing. 
 
The 'futile' comment needed a context and this comments board isn't the best place!! However - I think that certainly with re to the UFO issue your firm stance *against* it being a tangible phenomenon is these days so wide of the mark you are making yourselves irrelevant in my opinion.  
 
See you may not create a dichotomy between the whole "psychics" [cold reading etc] field and exopolitics or the wider UFO/ET issue but we see nothing that makes the field 'supern
4"Evidence - or lack of"
at Tuesday, 01 December 2009 17:15by Trystan
Hi, thanks for the comments. I still beg to differ over Larry Warren and the Jim Penniston notebook. 
 
In regard to questions, no good interview ever sticks to set questions. We had some, but by no means were all from the cribsheet. Sometimes they get raised as a direct result of the conversation. 
 
David, I'm a little surprised you view the skeptical approach as 'futile'. I don't think that's helpful as it misses the point. We are interested in evidence and as such exopolitics isn't complex. To suggest we should just accept the reality of exopolitics with nothing but anecdotal evidence is bad reasoning. I guess we should believe in Zeus because so many people used to! To take your reasoning to its conclusion then we must believe in Zeus, Allah, God, ghosts, dragons etc because at one point there was lots of anecdotal evidence for their existence. We don't say that aliens do not exist, but until there is solid evidence we doubt their presence. 
All the best 
Trystan (Semantic mauler
3"-"
at Monday, 23 November 2009 02:15by Shaun
There's no point engaging with these people - they are never going to shift an inch on how they perceive the issue. If you hear the discussions before your interview and after you can realise this.
2"interview"
at Monday, 16 November 2009 16:53by webadmin
Hi JAG - thanks for feedback... I don't know whether it's the done thing to get a list of questions. The only one that really threw me was them asking about direct Alien technology exchanges. But you live and learn.  
 
Don't forget that unless you are looking at over and hours unedited discussion - you don't get to do the FULL replies that are needed to qualify this complex area.  
 
Also - I think most people would have refused to be interviewed by a bunch like this but I think it's all bridge-building. After all it shows the futility of their stance. We only have to be right once. 
 
PS: Trystan [main interviewer] *was* wrong on Jim Penniston and the military notebook in which he made symbols. He was also wrong on Larry Warren not being present. Larry has always said he was there on night 3.  
 
davID, WebAdmin.
1"into the lions"
at Monday, 16 November 2009 17:32by j.*A*.g
good interview! Pity the skeptic pack couldn't allow you to make some decent responses before they started mauling you and playing the semantic game. As you eloquently put it above, it's a co-creational dimension of mystery. The need to endlessly prove all facets of the phenomenon using repeatable forms of evidence does nothing to advance the import of the experience, as felt and seen. 
 
Some of us, being touched by the mystery, are equally skeptical and want to challenge all assumptions to see the truth beneath, in its rawest form. 
 
In order to see the truth, one must be open and as you say in the interview, appreciate when something's "true enough", in order to plumb the deeper dimensions of being and appreception of the phenomenon. 
 
bravo DavID! 
 
(but next time, maybe get the questions written down before hand, so you've got at least a sporting chance of full reply, eh?)
» Post Comment Exopolitics UK site guests need to enter the anti-spam code.
Email (will not be published)
Name
Comment Topic
Comment
 remaining characters
Captcha Image Regenerate code when it's unreadable
Last Updated ( Monday, 15 March 2010 )
 
A Ut0piated Data Management System


- We create highly functional, database driven content management systems :: More -

The Saucer Is The OverSoul of Humanity...

online tests

 



Bookmark and Share cheap viagra online buy generic cialis online cheap generic india viagra buy viagra in england rx cialis low price purchase cheap viagra online purchase viagra online canada order generic cialis discount order viagra generic viagra money order discount generic viagra blue pill buy generic viagra viagra where to buy generic viagra woman cialis non generic cheap propecia uk order viagra visit your doctor online buy cheap avodart online cheapest place to buy viagra online india pharmacy viagra buy cheap generic propecia cheapest place to buy cialis silagra sale cheap generic buy viagra cheap viagra without prescription order generic viagra walmart price for viagra buy casodex cheap uk buy online viagra cheapest price viagra canadian discount pharmicies viagra cialis pharmacy on line viagra discount buy levitra in canada discount drug propecia low cost viagra buy cheap viagra prescription online where can i purchase viagra in the uk generic levitra from india cheap generic viagra viagra on sale generic viagra lowest price buy fast propecia buy viagra now generic cialis canada cheapest 4 quantity viagra cheap cialis sale online viagra generic low price buy viagra cheap generic propecia canada cheap cialis for sale in dublin free viagra order online discount generic cialis cheap viagra for men order viagra online cheap prices for viagra online pharmacy propecia buy propecia online without prescription buy generic cialis cheap viagra online without prescription cheapest price for viagra canada pharmacy viagra without prescription cheap generic overnight viagra buy cialis online prescription free cheap generic buy viagra cheap viagra without prescription price of viagra on the nhs where to buy acomplia discount sale viagra generic viagra pill best generic viagra nizagara tablets cheap generic cialis viagra sale online buy cialis no prescription buy viagra pill cyber pharmacy xenical lowest cost viagra acomplia online pharmacy uk pharmacies cheap viagra cheap viagra prices order cialis daily order viagra now viagra for sale lancashire cialis and viagra discount prices discount drug viagra purchase viagra online cheap form of orlistat buy propecia generic cheap pfizer viagra generic india levitra order propecia online generic name viagra best price viagra buy viagra online canadian viagra pills buy where can i buy viagra online viagra order order levitra online where to order cialis online how to buy cialis buy cheap viagra online buy generic propecia discount generic viagra usa rx is cialis available in generic online viagra order discount pfizer viagra cialis canada generic 10mg no prescription purchase viagra online canada canadian pharmacy for revatio 20 mg cheapest price for viagra lowest viagra price viagra cheap canada northwest cheap discount viagra buy cialis with no prescription cheap cialis no prescription cheap cialis no prescription buy cialis and discount prices tadalafil cialis from india cialis 100mg cialis price 100 mg buy viagra australian reliable viagra from india buy cialis soft online purchase cheap viagra online buying generic viagra without prescription cheapest viagra substitut cheapest viagra prices without a prescription buy generic viagra online uk pharmacies cheap viagra buy viagra canada buy viagra in uk cialis online purchase generic pharmacy canada viagra cialis 20 mg prices best price cialis without prescription cialis and viagra discount prices cheap generic viagra no prescription online cheap viagra buy cialis non generic buy viagra prescription buy cialis online now order propecia uk generic viagra soft pharmacy online cheap generic buy viagra cheap viagra order online buy generic propecia generic no prescription viagra best price viagra order generic levitra buy cheap viagra online buy propecia online generic cialis money order buy generic xenical 20mg cialis buy 5mg propecia order generic viagra viagra pro without prescription generic for viagra generic viagra cheap no prescription cheap viagra tablet online canadian pharmacy cialis viagra online store discount propecia online buying real viagra online online cheap viagra buy cialis canada pharmacy buy viagra online cheap viagra 100mg price buy discount cialis lowest price levitra generic online cheap discount generic cialis soft tabs buy levitra viagra buy propecia shampoo generic viagra sales mail order viagra without prescription us pharmacy selling levitra buy xenical orlistat cheapest online viagra discount drug propecia cialis sale uk canada no prescription viagra buy cialis uk best price levitra generic viagra levitra generic cialis pills buy levitra professional canadian pharmacy online viagra discount sale viagra cialis lowest prices discount generic viagra panama discount levitra pharmacy purchase cheap viagra order propecia long term buy cheapest price viagra deliverd uk find cheap cialis cialis levitra sale viagra cheap price on viagra best buy generic cialis where to buy viagra acomplia no prescription online xenical buy buy propecia and proscar discount generic viagra blue pill cialis and viagra discount prices discount cialis levitra viagra soft tab viagra online discount propecia online order cialis without prescription cheap foreign generic viagra online cialis purchase viagra for sale without a prescription cialis discount pharmacy purchasing viagra in the united kingdom generic cialis softtab cheap pfizer viagra cheap soft viagra walmart pharmacy viagra cost buy levitra online viagra order cheap levitra viagra canada cheap buy propecia without a prescription buy viagra sydney best cialis price discount priced viagra cheap viagra search generic buy internet viagra discount generic viagra usa rx canadian pharmacy generic viagra where to buy xenical discount drugs viagra 100mg blue order pill viagra low cost levitra find the cheapest viagra for sale generic cialis from canada cialis softabs generic canadian pharmacy generic viagra pfizer viagra sale purchase viagra online without prescription viagra cheapest online viagra uk sale levitra cheap canada best generic cialis best buy cialis buy viagra online at discount price cheapest viagra to buy online in uk purchase cheap viagra buy generic levitra online cheapest generic price viagra cheap pill viagra female viagra cheap buy levitra vardenafil india pharmacy viagra viagra sale uk generic viagra online female viagra tablets cheap